What did Franklin mean by if we can keep it? Is it worth keeping? If we value living as a republic, why can't we do it and find statist slavery to be the better alternative? What do you believe would be necessary for American citizens to do in order to sustain the Republic?“A Republic, If You Can Keep It”
September 8, 2016 by Danna Bell
This post was written by Lee Ann Potter, the Director of Educational Outreach at the Library of Congress.
a (1) : a government having a chief of state who is not a monarch and who in modern times is usually a president (2) : a political unit (as a nation) having such a form of government
b (1) : a government in which supreme power resides in a body of citizens entitled to vote and is exercised by elected officers and representatives responsible to them and governing according to law
(definition courtesy of the Merriam-Webster Dictionary)
In anticipation of Constitution Day, our “Sources and Strategies” article in the September 2016 issue of Social Education, the journal of the National Council for the Social Studies, suggested provoking student interest in civic responsibility with an 18th century diary entry. The featured entry was that of James McHenry, written on September 18, 1787.
McHenry was an Irish immigrant who served as an aide to Washington, and later to Lafayette, during the Revolutionary War. He was selected to serve as a delegate to the federal convention (that became known as the “Constitutional Convention”) from Maryland and upon his arrival in Philadelphia began keeping his personal journal. Due to an unexpected illness of his brother, however, McHenry returned home and missed much of the convention—from June 1 to August 4—but the information he included when he was present was quite detailed.
For example, the day after McHenry and the other delegates signed the Constitution and officially adjourned—he recorded the following exchange:
“a lady asked Dr. Franklin
well Doctor what we got
a republic or a monarchy—
A republic replied the Doctor
if you can keep it.
The lady here aluded [sic] to was
Mrs. Powel of Philadelphia”
We suggested sharing this page with students, confirming that they know what a monarchy and a republic are, and then asking them what they think Benjamin Franklin meant by “if you can keep it.”
We then proposed recording student responses and generating a class list of specific behaviors required to maintain a republic, and finally providing students with an opportunity to conduct original research about the Constitutional Convention, the delegates, Eliza Powel, and their understanding of a republic.
If you tried these suggestions, or a variation of them, with your students, please tell us about your experience!
If such ideas are not taught in schools the gradual descent into statist slavery seems inevitable.
HB America even if you are a dying society with no comprehension of what will be lost.