Philosophy Now Forum

Harbal

''So what are we to do?" well, what is the answer? Kropotkin You do what you like, Kropotkin, but I intend to carry on as normal. K: but why? you are acting ''normally'' which is great, but without questioning why? and I must ask, what is ''normal?" Maybe, normal for you is to have sex wi...

Harbal

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed May 29, 2024 6:06 pm
Harbal wrote: ↑Wed May 29, 2024 4:34 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed May 29, 2024 2:55 pm
Then again...why are you even talking?
It's part of my campaign for more honesty on the forum.
Start at home, and maybe you'll manage something.

I did start at home, quite some time ago.

Harbal

Peter Kropotkin wrote: ↑Wed May 29, 2024 5:32 pm

''So what are we to do?" well, what is the answer?

Kropotkin

You do what you like, Kropotkin, but I intend to carry on as normal.

Harbal

I just hate it when people insist on taking an impartial, factual approach.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xAs5EOBUDcs

Harbal

Not "my" facts. Lindsay's evidence. If you're not afraid of evidence, go and read the book. If you're not interested in evidence, then why are you flapping your gums? 🤤 I'm not interested in this particular instance... Then again...why are you even talking? It's part of my campaign for mo...

Harbal

Not at all. Why would I expect that? But you'll notice that I'm the one who's pointing you to the documentation. For some reason, I'm not afraid of the facts...🤔 Having encountered your "facts" on numerous occasions, I always think it wise to handle them with extreme caution. Not "my...

Harbal

Well, sorry to say, but that's what you get for trusting Wikipedia But we are safe to trust you, right? 🙂 Not at all. Why would I expect that? But you'll notice that I'm the one who's pointing you to the documentation. For some reason, I'm not afraid of the facts...🤔 Having encountered your "f...

Harbal

."Cultural" Marxism is a variation of Marxism. You're now speaking of "Classical" or "Economic" Marxism. Not according to the ever reliable Wikipedia: "Cultural Marxism" refers to a far-right antisemitic conspiracy theory that misrepresents the Frankfurt Scho...

Harbal

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon May 27, 2024 8:48 pm
Peter Kropotkin wrote: ↑Mon May 27, 2024 7:08 pm... the fact is that we on the left
don't think in terms of Marxism...
That's because you're a perfect example of Lenin's term, "useful idiots."
Do you have any evidence to support your accusation of usefulness?

Harbal

I do not believe in the supernatural so god is out. Then so is my question. You do not wish to discuss meaning in general? No. I'm just a bit fed up with being told that if I don't believe in God, life/existence must have no meaning for me. Well I just wanted to know what meaning it has when you be...

Harbal

The topic is meaning, what is your topic? Biology is the measure and the meaning of all things, without subjective consciousness there is nothing on a subjective level, and the subjective level is the only level we have. I have heard it said that without God there is no meaning to life. My question...

Harbal

The topic is meaning, what is your topic? Biology is the measure and the meaning of all things, without subjective consciousness there is nothing on a subjective level, and the subjective level is the only level we have. I have heard it said that without God there is no meaning to life. My question...

Harbal

You miss my point, that you have circled back to what the context Harbal in his OP has asked without actually providing an answer. Sure, conscious minds are required to quiz the "meaning of life" - but you still haven't answered that question. This is why I don't start many threads: I ask...

Harbal

FFS popeye - The ultimate science we have is physics - IT is the measure that GIVES any "meaning" to these "all things"/ Biology is the 3rd tier (after chemistry) Your conclusion that absent of consciousness the world (*lets state the universe*) is utterly meaningless requires y...

Harbal

Peter Kropotkin wrote: ↑Sun May 26, 2024 7:13 pm Even a cursory look at modern history,
tells us the modern quest has been for certainty......

And what preceded it; the quest for not quite sure?

Philosophy Now Forum

Search found 10124 matches

Re: questions of philosophy.....

Re: WOKE and proud of it....

Re: questions of philosophy.....

Re: TRUMP AHEAD?

Re: WOKE and proud of it....

Re: WOKE and proud of it....

Re: WOKE and proud of it....

Re: WOKE and proud of it....

Re: WOKE and proud of it....

Re: Meaning?

Re: Meaning?

Re: Meaning?

Re: Meaning?

Re: Meaning?

Re: philosophical quest and modernity