Philosophy Now Forum

Harbal

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon May 27, 2024 8:48 pm
Peter Kropotkin wrote: ↑Mon May 27, 2024 7:08 pm... the fact is that we on the left
don't think in terms of Marxism...
That's because you're a perfect example of Lenin's term, "useful idiots."
Do you have any evidence to support your accusation of usefulness?

Harbal

I do not believe in the supernatural so god is out. Then so is my question. You do not wish to discuss meaning in general? No. I'm just a bit fed up with being told that if I don't believe in God, life/existence must have no meaning for me. Well I just wanted to know what meaning it has when you be...

Harbal

The topic is meaning, what is your topic? Biology is the measure and the meaning of all things, without subjective consciousness there is nothing on a subjective level, and the subjective level is the only level we have. I have heard it said that without God there is no meaning to life. My question...

Harbal

The topic is meaning, what is your topic? Biology is the measure and the meaning of all things, without subjective consciousness there is nothing on a subjective level, and the subjective level is the only level we have. I have heard it said that without God there is no meaning to life. My question...

Harbal

You miss my point, that you have circled back to what the context Harbal in his OP has asked without actually providing an answer. Sure, conscious minds are required to quiz the "meaning of life" - but you still haven't answered that question. This is why I don't start many threads: I ask...

Harbal

FFS popeye - The ultimate science we have is physics - IT is the measure that GIVES any "meaning" to these "all things"/ Biology is the 3rd tier (after chemistry) Your conclusion that absent of consciousness the world (*lets state the universe*) is utterly meaningless requires y...

Harbal

Peter Kropotkin wrote: ↑Sun May 26, 2024 7:13 pm Even a cursory look at modern history,
tells us the modern quest has been for certainty......

And what preceded it; the quest for not quite sure?

Harbal

BTW. I have been wondering Y you have decided to talk to me again? It's for now. So long as you are civil in regard to sacred matters, and don't blaspheme. Otherwise, as a Christian, my interest in your welfare would compel me to stop engaging you so you didn't condemn yourself, and so that I didn'...

Harbal

I don't think it will be bought, other than as a novelty or fun gift...even by the most conservative Christians. And it will certainly not be read or used, except for fun. I thought some of your ideas about morality were strange, but I can't even begin to imagine what your idea of fun must be. 🤔 It...

Harbal

I suppose that's why so many evangelical Christians here in America will go out and buy Trump's Bible. After all, Trump is a True Christian, right? Why take chances when their very soul is on the line. I don't get your reasoning here. Owning Trump's Bible will make you a True Christian? Reading Tru...

Harbal

Age wrote: ↑Sat May 25, 2024 6:44 pm
Harbal wrote: ↑Sat May 25, 2024 5:37 pm People just haven't got the patience to answer all your questions.
And/or do not have the 'know-how', which really is quite contradictory, when looked at and delved into fully

I wouldn't know; I haven't fully delved into it.

Harbal

There's a reason that there are teachers in the world, lots of them, in every field. But that's not popular these days, when people want to believe that they can learn anything on their own. Even if one chooses to learn from a "teacher," one will be an immeasurably better "student&qu...

Harbal

OK. What are you rebelling against? Who are you rebelling on behalf of? By "human rebellion" do you mean you're rebelling against non-humans? My studies of traditional Catholic Christianity has opened my eyes to a religio-metaphysical method of seeing this reality and living in it with a ...

Harbal

you may find them pointless. But, until you ever begin answering them they will remain alongside your other pointless presumptions here. you find other's beliefs as being meaningless here, yet your beliefs have no more meaning at all. you keep missing the Fact that it is what you are 'currently' be...

Harbal

How could a rational thinking human beings get a 'headache' just from reading words and/or questions? Most rational people would just give up doing a completely unnecessary thing if it gave them headaches. And that is exactly why I've decided to stop answering all your pintless questions. you may f...

Philosophy Now Forum

Search found 10116 matches

Re: WOKE and proud of it....

Re: Meaning?

Re: Meaning?

Re: Meaning?

Re: Meaning?

Re: Meaning?

Re: philosophical quest and modernity

Re: TRUMP AHEAD?

Re: TRUMP AHEAD?

Re: TRUMP AHEAD?

Re: Meaning?

Re: TRUMP AHEAD?

Re: TRUMP AHEAD?

Re: Meaning?

Re: Meaning?