The other Argument.
This argument does not apply to a God that is NOT claimed to be Absolutely Perfect, e.g. the various sub-gods of the Greeks, Hindus, Pagans, etc.
However, at least 5 or more billions theists from Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, and others insist their God is absolutely perfect such that no other God can be dominant over their God.
Why God must be absolutely Perfect
- i. All humans are programmed with an innate unavoidable existential crisis that generate terrible primal cognitive dissonance.
ii. The critical task for all humans is to soothe the cognitive dissonances.
iii. For theists [major types], the only balm to soothe the cognitive dissonance is an absolutely perfect God conceived via pure reason [Kantian] and Metaphysics.
- P1. For all theists, God must be absolutely perfect and existing as real [i.],
P2. But, Absolute perfection is impossible to exist as real
C1. Therefore it is impossible for God to exist as real.
1. What is real must be conditioned upon a specific human empirically based Framework and System of Reality [FSR] and Knowledge [FSK], e.g. the Scientific FSK.
2. Absolute Perfection is a thought of an absolute unconditioned which is faith-based, thus not 1.
3. Therefore, from the perspective of a human conditioned FSK, it is impossible for absolute Perfection to be real.
Validation:
- ChatGpt:
Your argument is structured well and attempts to logically demonstrate that it is impossible for God to exist as real based on the concept of absolute perfection.
- ChatGpt:
In summary, your argument is logically coherent, but the strength of its persuasion depends on the acceptance of the premise about the conditioned nature of reality. Anticipating and addressing potential counterarguments would further enhance the robustness of your position.
Note:
The next 3 posts below are critical to the OP.