Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

For all things philosophical.

Moderators: AMod, iMod

Post Reply
Maia
Posts: 800
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2022 8:11 am
Location: UK

Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Maia »

They live around humans all the time, but do they ever wonder why they are different to us? Has any of them, even a single individual, ever had the self-awareness to do so? I suppose we can never really know, but we can speculate, based on our very long and thorough experience of them. And my answer is, no, such a question probably never even crosses their minds. And this, I think, is probably a very good thing, from their point of view.
Skepdick
Posts: 14364
Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2019 11:16 am

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Skepdick »

Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 6:52 am They live around humans all the time, but do they ever wonder why they are different to us? Has any of them, even a single individual, ever had the self-awareness to do so? I suppose we can never really know, but we can speculate, based on our very long and thorough experience of them. And my answer is, no, such a question probably never even crosses their minds. And this, I think, is probably a very good thing, from their point of view.
It would be a shame if it they were to ask such questions. It will take them way longer than it took us humans (+-2500 years) to figure out that questions of identity are meaningless.

What we are is undecidable.
Maia
Posts: 800
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2022 8:11 am
Location: UK

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Maia »

Skepdick wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:00 am
Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 6:52 am They live around humans all the time, but do they ever wonder why they are different to us? Has any of them, even a single individual, ever had the self-awareness to do so? I suppose we can never really know, but we can speculate, based on our very long and thorough experience of them. And my answer is, no, such a question probably never even crosses their minds. And this, I think, is probably a very good thing, from their point of view.
It would be a shame if it they were to ask such questions. It will take them way longer than it took us humans (+-2500 years) to figure out that questions of identity are meaningless.

What we are is undecidable.
We can learn a lot from them. Within reason, of course.
Skepdick
Posts: 14364
Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2019 11:16 am

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Skepdick »

Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:03 am
Skepdick wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:00 am
Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 6:52 am They live around humans all the time, but do they ever wonder why they are different to us? Has any of them, even a single individual, ever had the self-awareness to do so? I suppose we can never really know, but we can speculate, based on our very long and thorough experience of them. And my answer is, no, such a question probably never even crosses their minds. And this, I think, is probably a very good thing, from their point of view.
It would be a shame if it they were to ask such questions. It will take them way longer than it took us humans (+-2500 years) to figure out that questions of identity are meaningless.

What we are is undecidable.
We can learn a lot from them. Within reason, of course.
Yep. We sure had to fail a lot at arriving at any satisfactory answers about who we are before we even bothered to ask whether there is a problem with the question.
Maia
Posts: 800
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2022 8:11 am
Location: UK

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Maia »

Skepdick wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:08 am
Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:03 am
Skepdick wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:00 am
It would be a shame if it they were to ask such questions. It will take them way longer than it took us humans (+-2500 years) to figure out that questions of identity are meaningless.

What we are is undecidable.
We can learn a lot from them. Within reason, of course.
Yep. We sure had to fail a lot at arriving at any satisfactory answers about who we are before we even bothered to ask whether there is a problem with the question.
We are what we are and that needs no explaining... Hang on, no, that's just a song.
User avatar
attofishpi
Posts: 9956
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2011 8:10 am
Location: Orion Spur
Contact:

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by attofishpi »

Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 6:52 am They live around humans all the time, but do they ever wonder why they are different to us? Has any of them, even a single individual, ever had the self-awareness to do so? I suppose we can never really know, but we can speculate, based on our very long and thorough experience of them. And my answer is, no, such a question probably never even crosses their minds. And this, I think, is probably a very good thing, from their point of view.
Probably.

This thread today you just created is so similar to a thread I have been thinking about creating.

But only about dogs (I'm not familiar with cats, but I hear good things :)

My best friend, Donnie, is 4 and we hang out all day together. Yesterday he convinced me while I was working on the compooter to take him for a walk. I needed to get to the shops and was considering the car was a wise move.
Well, it had been raining all morning, but it then stopped. Donnie decided it was time for some fresh air, so he started nudging my arms as I continue to - attempt to - tap away at the keys, until I caved and thought yep, we can go thru the park, and then get to the shops.
Well, we got drenched on the way back from the shops! I get his towel and dry him off as much as possible before letting him inside. BUT, this is the important part - I put a little squeezy piggy toy that always freaked him out, so he keeps away from it, and the ball slinger thingy on the couch, so soggy dog Donnie, doesn't mess up the couch! He's got a little rug he can dry off on.

..anyway, the thread I want and probably will create is not so much about your question title.

I TRULY attempt to teach English to my dog mostly about objects, "there's piggy!", "there's ball" etc..
Maia
Posts: 800
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2022 8:11 am
Location: UK

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Maia »

attofishpi wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:16 am
Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 6:52 am They live around humans all the time, but do they ever wonder why they are different to us? Has any of them, even a single individual, ever had the self-awareness to do so? I suppose we can never really know, but we can speculate, based on our very long and thorough experience of them. And my answer is, no, such a question probably never even crosses their minds. And this, I think, is probably a very good thing, from their point of view.
Probably.

This thread today you just created is so similar to a thread I have been thinking about creating.

But only about dogs (I'm not familiar with cats, but I hear good things :)

My best friend, Donnie, is 4 and we hang out all day together. Yesterday he convinced me while I was working on the compooter to take him for a walk. I needed to get to the shops and was considering the car was a wise move.
Well, it had been raining all morning, but it then stopped. Donnie decided it was time for some fresh air, so he started nudging my arms as I continue to - attempt to - tap away at the keys, until I caved and thought yep, we can go thru the park, and then get to the shops.
Well, we got drenched on the way back from the shops! I get his towel and dry him off as much as possible before letting him inside. BUT, this is the important part - I put a little squeezy piggy toy that always freaked him out, so he keeps away from it, and the ball slinger thingy on the couch, so soggy dog Donnie, doesn't mess up the couch! He's got a little rug he can dry off on.

..anyway, the thread I want and probably will create is not so much about your question title.

I TRULY attempt to teach English to my dog mostly about objects, "there's piggy!", "there's ball" etc..
He sounds lovely, and so cute. I'm more familiar with cats than dogs, and although I don't have one myself, my parents do, and always have, and I grew up with them. I'm also quite familiar with service dogs, though again, have never owned one, but I know how intelligent they can be, both on an emotional and very practical level. And dogs, in particular, are quite capable of learning a whole range of words and commands. Less so with cats, admittedly, but both cats and dogs are very quick indeed to pick up on moods and atmosphere, and there is never any difficulty in communicating ones intentions to them, nor indeed, vice versa.
User avatar
Dontaskme
Posts: 16940
Joined: Sat Mar 12, 2016 2:07 pm
Location: Nowhere

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Dontaskme »

Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 6:52 am They live around humans all the time, but do they ever wonder why they are different to us? Has any of them, even a single individual, ever had the self-awareness to do so? I suppose we can never really know, but we can speculate, based on our very long and thorough experience of them. And my answer is, no, such a question probably never even crosses their minds. And this, I think, is probably a very good thing, from their point of view.
And that's what in my opinion makes animals luckier than humans, they don't take offence to being called all sorts of derogatory names.
Maia
Posts: 800
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2022 8:11 am
Location: UK

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Maia »

Dontaskme wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:31 am
Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 6:52 am They live around humans all the time, but do they ever wonder why they are different to us? Has any of them, even a single individual, ever had the self-awareness to do so? I suppose we can never really know, but we can speculate, based on our very long and thorough experience of them. And my answer is, no, such a question probably never even crosses their minds. And this, I think, is probably a very good thing, from their point of view.
And that's what in my opinion makes animals luckier than humans, they don't take offence to being called all sorts of derogatory names.
True, but they can be hurt, emotionally, in other ways. Perhaps even more so than people.
User avatar
attofishpi
Posts: 9956
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2011 8:10 am
Location: Orion Spur
Contact:

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by attofishpi »

Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:27 am
attofishpi wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:16 am
Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 6:52 am They live around humans all the time, but do they ever wonder why they are different to us? Has any of them, even a single individual, ever had the self-awareness to do so? I suppose we can never really know, but we can speculate, based on our very long and thorough experience of them. And my answer is, no, such a question probably never even crosses their minds. And this, I think, is probably a very good thing, from their point of view.
Probably.

This thread today you just created is so similar to a thread I have been thinking about creating.

But only about dogs (I'm not familiar with cats, but I hear good things :)

My best friend, Donnie, is 4 and we hang out all day together. Yesterday he convinced me while I was working on the compooter to take him for a walk. I needed to get to the shops and was considering the car was a wise move.
Well, it had been raining all morning, but it then stopped. Donnie decided it was time for some fresh air, so he started nudging my arms as I continue to - attempt to - tap away at the keys, until I caved and thought yep, we can go thru the park, and then get to the shops.
Well, we got drenched on the way back from the shops! I get his towel and dry him off as much as possible before letting him inside. BUT, this is the important part - I put a little squeezy piggy toy that always freaked him out, so he keeps away from it, and the ball slinger thingy on the couch, so soggy dog Donnie, doesn't mess up the couch! He's got a little rug he can dry off on.

..anyway, the thread I want and probably will create is not so much about your question title.

I TRULY attempt to teach English to my dog mostly about objects, "there's piggy!", "there's ball" etc..
He sounds lovely, and so cute. I'm more familiar with cats than dogs, and although I don't have one myself, my parents do, and always have, and I grew up with them. I'm also quite familiar with service dogs, though again, have never owned one, but I know how intelligent they can be, both on an emotional and very practical level. And dogs, in particular, are quite capable of learning a whole range of words and commands. Less so with cats, admittedly, but both cats and dogs are very quick indeed to pick up on moods and atmosphere, and there is never any difficulty in communicating ones intentions to them, nor indeed, vice versa.
Yes, and it puzzles me so often because I know Donnie is intelligent and sentient - (it's a puzzle as to how they think!) We think mostly with our words within our heads.

Donnie is 75% Golden Retriever - the rest Border Collie - two very intelligent breeds. (he is black - half the litter were golden and half black - he was the last of the litter and I drove over 400kms to get my best mate) I rarely bother with a lead for him unless near busy roads. Where we live there are 3 main different walks into nature I can take him on so he is off the lead most of the time. If I tell him to stop\wait he does
and the I say "ok\go on" - no problem - so joggers, people on bikes etc well, they appreciate it.
Maia
Posts: 800
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2022 8:11 am
Location: UK

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Maia »

attofishpi wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:37 am
Maia wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:27 am
attofishpi wrote: Tue May 30, 2023 7:16 am

Probably.

This thread today you just created is so similar to a thread I have been thinking about creating.

But only about dogs (I'm not familiar with cats, but I hear good things :)

My best friend, Donnie, is 4 and we hang out all day together. Yesterday he convinced me while I was working on the compooter to take him for a walk. I needed to get to the shops and was considering the car was a wise move.
Well, it had been raining all morning, but it then stopped. Donnie decided it was time for some fresh air, so he started nudging my arms as I continue to - attempt to - tap away at the keys, until I caved and thought yep, we can go thru the park, and then get to the shops.
Well, we got drenched on the way back from the shops! I get his towel and dry him off as much as possible before letting him inside. BUT, this is the important part - I put a little squeezy piggy toy that always freaked him out, so he keeps away from it, and the ball slinger thingy on the couch, so soggy dog Donnie, doesn't mess up the couch! He's got a little rug he can dry off on.

..anyway, the thread I want and probably will create is not so much about your question title.

I TRULY attempt to teach English to my dog mostly about objects, "there's piggy!", "there's ball" etc..
He sounds lovely, and so cute. I'm more familiar with cats than dogs, and although I don't have one myself, my parents do, and always have, and I grew up with them. I'm also quite familiar with service dogs, though again, have never owned one, but I know how intelligent they can be, both on an emotional and very practical level. And dogs, in particular, are quite capable of learning a whole range of words and commands. Less so with cats, admittedly, but both cats and dogs are very quick indeed to pick up on moods and atmosphere, and there is never any difficulty in communicating ones intentions to them, nor indeed, vice versa.
Yes, and it puzzles me so often because I know Donnie is intelligent and sentient - (it's a puzzle as to how they think!) We think mostly with our words within our heads.

Donnie is 75% Golden Retriever - the rest Border Collie - two very intelligent breeds. I rarely bother with a lead for him unless near busy roads. Where we live there are 3 main different walks into nature I can take him on so he is off the lead most of the time. If I tell him to stop\wait he does
and the I say "ok\go on" - no problem - so joggers, people on bikes etc well, they appreciate it.
Thinking without words is indeed a very strange concept to get one's head around, and is impossible to imagine. But they undoubtedly do. Not in the same way that we do, for sure, but they must have a certain level of conscious thought. It is also in the nature of dogs to be loyal and obedient to their "owners" since this instinct derives from their wolfish ancestry, hunting in packs, following the leader.
Jayden
Posts: 1
Joined: Thu Jun 15, 2023 8:57 am
Contact:

Re: Do cats and dogs ever wonder what they are?

Post by Jayden »

An interesting question you raise about how animals perceive themselves and how they think about differences between humans. Although we can speculate, considering the vast amount of experience we have had with them, it is unlikely that animals have the same self-knowledge to think about such questions Usually focus their immediate needs and survival rather than self-examination of their uniqueness. In a sense, this lack of self can contribute to their contentment and natural integration with their surroundings.
Post Reply