Dubious wrote: ↑Wed Dec 25, 2019 5:13 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Dec 25, 2019 3:05 am
But what makes evil "evil," dub?
Are you saying you haven't lived long enough to know??
If this were a reasonable answer, then you'd be implying that people "just know," by instinct. And maybe they do: but it would take a lot of elaborate explaining to explain how they do; or why we know that when they do, they're right.
Worse still for that simplistic answer, is that different people and cultures hold to different moral values. How does one go about explaining that, for example, homosexuality is fine in 'Frisco, but will get you killed in Syria? It looks very much as though these "intuition" people are having are rather different.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Dec 25, 2019 3:05 amThe Big Bang does not supply values. There is, then, no evil, and no good -- only what
is.
Pray! What does the BB have to do with it?
The BB is an accident in space. If that's our origin point, then from where do morals come, and how are they to be shown legitimate?
In short, no evil, no good, the whole enchilada of existence signifying NOTHING!
Then your earlier claim that the brain is "twisted" or "debased" or "corruptible," and your claim that "evil" comes from there -- these are really things you do
not believe -- or if you still believe them, then you believe them without good reason, and you cannot warrant them rationally.
Or can you? What's your warrant for calling anything "evil"? (or "twisted," or "debased," or whatever such word you wish to use in its place).