Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
This is a thought experiment that provides a dilemma for those like me you don't eat meat on ethical grounds.
The initial conditions are thus
1. you are stranded, with no hope of rescue or escape
2. there are others depending on you remaining alive for their survival, though they may soon be in a position to fend for themselves
Your only means of survival is to eat either
1. A still born baby
2. A freshly killed wild animal
All the best, rantal
The initial conditions are thus
1. you are stranded, with no hope of rescue or escape
2. there are others depending on you remaining alive for their survival, though they may soon be in a position to fend for themselves
Your only means of survival is to eat either
1. A still born baby
2. A freshly killed wild animal
All the best, rantal
- Bill Wiltrack
- Posts: 5468
- Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2007 1:52 pm
- Location: Cleveland, Ohio, USA
- Contact:
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
.
.......................................................................
I would choose number 1...although initially it doesn't sound like a vegetarian dish.
Is this a right/wrong type of test?
.
.......................................................................
I would choose number 1...although initially it doesn't sound like a vegetarian dish.
Is this a right/wrong type of test?
.
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
I see cats are now studying the uncertainty principle!
all the best, rantal
all the best, rantal
- Bill Wiltrack
- Posts: 5468
- Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2007 1:52 pm
- Location: Cleveland, Ohio, USA
- Contact:
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
.
.........................................................................................
.
.........................................................................................
.
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
I don't believe so, at least, I conceived it not as such but rather as a thought experimentI would choose number 1...although initially it doesn't sound like a vegetarian dish.
Is this a right/wrong type of test?
All the best, rantal
- Bill Wiltrack
- Posts: 5468
- Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2007 1:52 pm
- Location: Cleveland, Ohio, USA
- Contact:
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
.
Most importantly, since it's just the two of us here, what is YOUR choice & why?
.
Most importantly, since it's just the two of us here, what is YOUR choice & why?
.
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
Like you, I two would eat the baby, by revulsion of eating a human is overcome by disinclination to take a life
all the best, rantal
all the best, rantal
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
What if you need more food? What do you mean by "may soon be in a position to fend for themselves?" The potential meal you passed up is still subject to Darwin's world. BTY, welcome to the forum rantal.
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
I may need more food soon but those who depend upon me will soon be in a postion to look after themselves. That the potential meal is subject to predation is not relievant, as a vegetarian I do not attempt to prevent predationJohn K wrote:What if you need more food? What do you mean by "may soon be in a position to fend for themselves?" The potential meal you passed up is still subject to Darwin's world. BTY, welcome to the forum rantal.
all the best, rantal
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
I guess the real question is would the vegetarian act like Socrates; would he forfeit life in order to embrace the philosophy?
- Bill Wiltrack
- Posts: 5468
- Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2007 1:52 pm
- Location: Cleveland, Ohio, USA
- Contact:
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
.
..................................................
Wow...excellent question.
“ The liberally educated person is one who is able to resist the easy and preferred answers, not because he is obstinate but because he knows others worthy of consideration. ”
--- Allan Bloom ---
.
..................................................
Wow...excellent question.
“ The liberally educated person is one who is able to resist the easy and preferred answers, not because he is obstinate but because he knows others worthy of consideration. ”
--- Allan Bloom ---
.
- Bill Wiltrack
- Posts: 5468
- Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2007 1:52 pm
- Location: Cleveland, Ohio, USA
- Contact:
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
.
..................................................................................
.......................................................................................................From Farm to Fridge
.....................................................................................................Bon appétit. Are you a vegetarian?
.
..................................................................................
.......................................................................................................From Farm to Fridge
.....................................................................................................Bon appétit. Are you a vegetarian?
.
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
I had considered that but by introducing the need to stay alive to help others made the question examine the reasons for the person being a vegetarian.John K wrote:I guess the real question is would the vegetarian act like Socrates; would he forfeit life in order to embrace the philosophy?
Those vegetarian for ethical reasons should, I maintain, opt to eat the still born baby those who are vegetarian for other reasons may choose to kill and animal
all the best, rantal
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
If we manage to provide burgers without meat that taste better and make the eater feel better than after eating a burger with meat then we will progress towards vegetarianism.
I am a nearly vegetarian without doing any sacrifices. There are just too many things I sincerely prefer to meat.
At the moment I am warming up with hot water drinks and oats with dried figs, which sit in hot water for about an hour. The second bowl will be ready in about half an hour.
I am a nearly vegetarian without doing any sacrifices. There are just too many things I sincerely prefer to meat.
At the moment I am warming up with hot water drinks and oats with dried figs, which sit in hot water for about an hour. The second bowl will be ready in about half an hour.
Re: Vegtarian posses a dilemma for fellow vegetarians
What puts me off eating sausages and processed meat in general is that you never know for sure which animal was processed exactly (horse or cat or rat or worse) and which parts of the animal and what apart from the animal.
You just cannot recognize anything, the mixture is well done and looks rosy due to chemicals.
You just cannot recognize anything, the mixture is well done and looks rosy due to chemicals.