What brought the 'meaningful' word into this now, and why?Dontaskme wrote: ↑Thu Jan 06, 2022 1:09 pmSo have the meaningful answers come from a ( me ) and an ( I ) both as underlined ?Age wrote: ↑Thu Jan 06, 2022 12:30 pmIt is NOT about who 'knows' those definitions, it is about who gave those definitions for those words, and the answer is 'i' did, an individual human being, through a human body.
How those 'answers' are known is by 'you' reading them here.
Once you read what those words usually mean or refer to, to 'me', then that is how 'you' 'know' the answers that 'I' have provided here.
Those answers came from 'me', and if those answers can be agreed with and accepted by EVERY one, then they align with 'I'. So, the answer is 'Yes'.
Where did this 'meaningful' conception come from, EXACTLY? And, WHY was 'it' added into this discussion?
The answers, to the questions, obviously come from 'me', so, as you put those answers 'belong' to 'me'.
'I' KNOW that those answers could be agreed with and accepted by EVERY one, so that is WHY it is written above that 'I' provided those answers here.
It could be said that those answers were provided to 'me' (or a 'you') by thee 'I'. But 'we' would have to delve deeper into working out that 'we' are both using thee 'I' word the same way.
The 'me' word usually just means or refers to the 'one' speaking/writing.
The 'you' word usually just means or refers to an "other", from the 'one' speaking/writing.
The 'I' word usually just means or refers to EVERY one as One.
But do NOT forget 'you' are absolutely FREE to use ANY word ANY way 'you' like.
The above is just from 'my' or from 'My' perspective, ONLY.
BUT it IS about the WHO. I just SAID that in the quoted sentence above the one you just wrote here.
I SAID it is NOT about WHO 'knows' those definitions, it is about WHO 'gave' those definitions. So, VERY CLEARLY, I did SAY and state it IS about (the) WHO.
What do you think may have CAUSED 'you' to ASSUME that I was saying that it is NOT about (the) WHO?
It seems the ( i ) is also the ( who ) is that correct?
[/quote]
That would all depend on which 'who' 'you' are referring to here, EXACTLY?