is evolution shaped by death
is evolution shaped by death
Are evolved forms shaped by the invisible force of death. Is this invisible and unmoving force of death changing the moving things of life and is the evolution of species the life beond at work in nature.
- Hobbes' Choice
- Posts: 8364
- Joined: Fri Oct 25, 2013 11:45 am
Re: is evolution shaped by death
Yes, death is the most important thing about evolution as without it there would be none.jackles wrote:Are evolved forms shaped by the invisible force of death. Is this invisible and unmoving force of death changing the moving things of life and is the evolution of species the life beond at work in nature.
But you are wrong to characterise it as in invisible force, it is not such thing.
Death, and particularly untimely death is the means by which only successful behaviours and traits can persist into the next generation.
Evolution is the promotion of characteristics by means of individual members of species living long enough to have viable progeny. There is simply no other rubric.
Evolution is not the selection of positive traits. But the selection of successful individuals with collections of traits that can be neutral and even negative - (just so long as they are not detrimental enough to cause the individual to die before they create viable progeny).
As all living things have a negative propensity to death, it would appear obvious that such a negative trait is no impediment to evolution.
Re: is evolution shaped by death
Maybe a sidetrack but this is one of my favourite quotes:
"A scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."
~ ~ Max Planck
"A scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."
~ ~ Max Planck
Re: is evolution shaped by death
Is evolution shaped by death? Do you mean is it shaped by a 'death' of consciousness?
It is. I think a will to survive, a relationship with God; a will to transcend, to overcome... is obviously part of evolution. We have been viewing genetics in a very mechanical way up until recently, and as time goes on the field of genetics will continue to become less mechanical as we realize genes activate and deactivate; the brain is involved in this process, so consciousness therefor plays a role; thus evolution is influenced by consciousness, which is in turn directly influenced by beliefs. ......
It is. I think a will to survive, a relationship with God; a will to transcend, to overcome... is obviously part of evolution. We have been viewing genetics in a very mechanical way up until recently, and as time goes on the field of genetics will continue to become less mechanical as we realize genes activate and deactivate; the brain is involved in this process, so consciousness therefor plays a role; thus evolution is influenced by consciousness, which is in turn directly influenced by beliefs. ......
- Hobbes' Choice
- Posts: 8364
- Joined: Fri Oct 25, 2013 11:45 am
Re: is evolution shaped by death
Evolution is not related to God. Where have you been for the last 150 years; in a monkhouse?ianrust wrote:Is evolution shaped by death? Do you mean is it shaped by a 'death' of consciousness?
It is. I think a will to survive, a relationship with God; a will to transcend, to overcome... is obviously part of evolution. We have been viewing genetics in a very mechanical way up until recently, and as time goes on the field of genetics will continue to become less mechanical as we realize genes activate and deactivate; the brain is involved in this process, so consciousness therefor plays a role; thus evolution is influenced by consciousness, which is in turn directly influenced by beliefs. ......
Re: is evolution shaped by death
If I believe in God, I will behave differently than if I do not. That difference in behavior will effect how I reproduce, and survive. So yes, belief in God is directly related to evolution. Now, what?Hobbes' Choice wrote:Evolution is not related to God. Where have you been for the last 150 years; in a monkhouse?ianrust wrote:Is evolution shaped by death? Do you mean is it shaped by a 'death' of consciousness?
It is. I think a will to survive, a relationship with God; a will to transcend, to overcome... is obviously part of evolution. We have been viewing genetics in a very mechanical way up until recently, and as time goes on the field of genetics will continue to become less mechanical as we realize genes activate and deactivate; the brain is involved in this process, so consciousness therefor plays a role; thus evolution is influenced by consciousness, which is in turn directly influenced by beliefs. ......
- Arising_uk
- Posts: 12314
- Joined: Wed Oct 17, 2007 2:31 am
Re: is evolution shaped by death
Given that this field, along with Molecular Biology, is what has allowed Biology to at last become more than taxonomy and become an Engineering subject I think your thought in error. We now have a small grasp upon the 'Tree of Life' despite your 'God's' will.inrush wrote:... and as time goes on the field of genetics will continue to become less mechanical ...
Re: is evolution shaped by death
That is irrelevant. Genetics is changing, it's become more interactive and will continue to.Arising_uk wrote:Given that this field, along with Molecular Biology, is what has allowed Biology to at last become more than taxonomy and become an Engineering subject I think your thought in error. We now have a small grasp upon the 'Tree of Life' despite your 'God's' will.inrush wrote:... and as time goes on the field of genetics will continue to become less mechanical ...
- Hobbes' Choice
- Posts: 8364
- Joined: Fri Oct 25, 2013 11:45 am
Re: is evolution shaped by death
Like most religionists you don't understand evolution in the slightest.ianrust wrote:If I believe in God, I will behave differently than if I do not. That difference in behavior will effect how I reproduce, and survive. So yes, belief in God is directly related to evolution. Now, what?Hobbes' Choice wrote:Evolution is not related to God. Where have you been for the last 150 years; in a monkhouse?ianrust wrote:Is evolution shaped by death? Do you mean is it shaped by a 'death' of consciousness?
It is. I think a will to survive, a relationship with God; a will to transcend, to overcome... is obviously part of evolution. We have been viewing genetics in a very mechanical way up until recently, and as time goes on the field of genetics will continue to become less mechanical as we realize genes activate and deactivate; the brain is involved in this process, so consciousness therefor plays a role; thus evolution is influenced by consciousness, which is in turn directly influenced by beliefs. ......
You might as well say that eating bananas are directly related to evolution.
- Hobbes' Choice
- Posts: 8364
- Joined: Fri Oct 25, 2013 11:45 am
Re: is evolution shaped by death
That is an abuse of the term "interactive".ianrust wrote:That is irrelevant. Genetics is changing, it's become more interactive and will continue to.Arising_uk wrote:Given that this field, along with Molecular Biology, is what has allowed Biology to at last become more than taxonomy and become an Engineering subject I think your thought in error. We now have a small grasp upon the 'Tree of Life' despite your 'God's' will.inrush wrote:... and as time goes on the field of genetics will continue to become less mechanical ...
Re: is evolution shaped by death
It isn't. When a gene activates or deactivates according to behavior, that is an interactive relationship. Pick the word apart if you feel the need, waste your time.
Last edited by ianrust on Sun Apr 26, 2015 1:43 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Re: is evolution shaped by death
Eating bananas is directly related to evolution. Read:Hobbes' Choice wrote:Like most religionists you don't understand evolution in the slightest.ianrust wrote:If I believe in God, I will behave differently than if I do not. That difference in behavior will effect how I reproduce, and survive. So yes, belief in God is directly related to evolution. Now, what?Hobbes' Choice wrote:
Evolution is not related to God. Where have you been for the last 150 years; in a monkhouse?
You might as well say that eating bananas are directly related to evolution.
http://necsi.edu/projects/evolution/co- ... dator.html
- Hobbes' Choice
- Posts: 8364
- Joined: Fri Oct 25, 2013 11:45 am
Re: is evolution shaped by death
Clearly you need to investigate the word "DIRECTLY".ianrust wrote:Eating bananas is directly related to evolution. Read:Hobbes' Choice wrote:Like most religionists you don't understand evolution in the slightest.ianrust wrote: If I believe in God, I will behave differently than if I do not. That difference in behavior will effect how I reproduce, and survive. So yes, belief in God is directly related to evolution. Now, what?
You might as well say that eating bananas are directly related to evolution.
http://necsi.edu/projects/evolution/co- ... dator.html
- Hobbes' Choice
- Posts: 8364
- Joined: Fri Oct 25, 2013 11:45 am
Re: is evolution shaped by death
As I suspected you don't understand evolution.ianrust wrote:It isn't. When a gene activates or deactivates according to behavior, that is an interactive relationship. Pick the word apart if you feel the need, waste your time.
You are born and die with the same genome. Evolution works on the variable survival of individuals: those that have viable progeny against those that fail to reproduce.
Epigenetics may have a small role to play, but nothing uncovered by science changes the fact that nothing we do during our lives can change the genome, though some genes might get switched on or off (in a limited way), evolution runs on Natural Selection.
Re: is evolution shaped by death
No, you can extrapolate it. I'm not interested in picking apart your jargon for you. You do need to investigate "post modernism", though - that's a philosophy about language. THanks, bye.Hobbes' Choice wrote:Clearly you need to investigate the word "DIRECTLY".ianrust wrote:Eating bananas is directly related to evolution. Read:Hobbes' Choice wrote:
Like most religionists you don't understand evolution in the slightest.
You might as well say that eating bananas are directly related to evolution.
http://necsi.edu/projects/evolution/co- ... dator.html