"Can your 13 year old freely (as in without consequences) ignore your dictatorship?"
Yeah, you know he can't, nor should he be able to: he's a child, yet to even imagine crap you & me, as adults, have confronted & then put behind us. Again: my job is to make him 'capable' (he ain't there yet).
"That is the exact same argument that can be made for having governments! Humans (in general) require oversight because we are collectively inexperienced and irresponsible."
Doesn't hold water: I for example, can take care of myself, I neither need or want an overseer. My 13 year old can't take care of himself, but -- if he thinks he can -- he has the option of winnin' emancipation.
Now: no doubt, there are adults as incapable as any 13 year old. I understand perfectly they want & need oversight. And they should have what they want. Just leave me out of it.
"We need oversight so as to avoid tragedies of the commons
which are detrimental to everyone, irrespective of political affiliation."
No, what we need is private owneship of those 'commons'.
"See? Common ground. Systemic harm prevention."
Nope. Seems to me you want someone to direct you (but you don't strike me as an incompetent) or direct others (but you don't strike me as a generally tyrannical type); me, I just wanna be left alone, wanna leave others alone.
So: we're not on the same page.