Banno wrote:Again, clarity and curtesy mark a conversation; but, given my objection to the first sentence of the OP, I want to know what makes such a conversation specifically philosophical.
Philosophy is specific to a large number of discourses. What determines if a particular discourse is a quality philosophical discussion would be determined by the level of discourse being conducted. Philosophy exists on a continuum. Where the discussion is on a continuum determines how the content is treated, not whether it is philosophical or not.
On a non-profession philosophical forum the quality can range from the very ordinary to the very good. Professional forums are of a higher standard.