Free will — an investigation
-
- Posts: 79
- Joined: Mon Aug 29, 2022 11:58 am
Free will — an investigation
Over the years, we have all seen many topics concerning free will. But one thing I have never seen — a clarification of what we mean by the concept of free will. That's what this topic is.
But this is not a definition-freak's topic, that demands a full, precise, and detailed definition, down to the last electron, before further discussion is permitted. Nothing so authoritarian!
This topic seeks to clarify free will. I have two questions to start with; you may have more to add?
1. What freedom(s) does free will bestow?
2. In contrast, what are the freedoms that free will does not, or cannot, bestow, if any?
In other words, if we do or did have free will, what impact would it have on our real-world lives? What are its effects? And if we don't have free will, what does that mean, in terms of real-world consequences?
But this is not a definition-freak's topic, that demands a full, precise, and detailed definition, down to the last electron, before further discussion is permitted. Nothing so authoritarian!
This topic seeks to clarify free will. I have two questions to start with; you may have more to add?
1. What freedom(s) does free will bestow?
2. In contrast, what are the freedoms that free will does not, or cannot, bestow, if any?
In other words, if we do or did have free will, what impact would it have on our real-world lives? What are its effects? And if we don't have free will, what does that mean, in terms of real-world consequences?
-
- Posts: 4368
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2010 2:04 pm
Re: Free will — an investigation
that which the body/mind is capable/incapable of doing...
-Imp
-Imp
-
- Posts: 79
- Joined: Mon Aug 29, 2022 11:58 am
Re: Free will — an investigation
Thanks. To which question(s) do your words respond?Impenitent wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 3:47 pm that which the body/mind is capable/incapable of doing...
-Imp
-
- Posts: 4368
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2010 2:04 pm
Re: Free will — an investigation
either/or
-Imp
-Imp
- henry quirk
- Posts: 14706
- Joined: Fri May 09, 2008 8:07 pm
- Location: Right here, a little less busy.
Re: Free will — an investigation
I am a free will. I am a point of causal & creative power. I begin, end, and bend at least some causal chains.
I am not a meat machine.
(I'm describin' myself as a libertarian agent [libertarian agent causation])
I am not a meat machine.
As a free will: I can begin, end, and bend at least some causal chains. Yesterday doesn't determine my today. I am free to attempt just about any damn thing I set my mind to, for any reason I suss out for myself.1. What freedom(s) does free will bestow?
Bein' a free will only means I can try: it doesn't guarantee success or that my choices are wise or right.2. In contrast, what are the freedoms that free will does not, or cannot, bestow, if any?
(I'm describin' myself as a libertarian agent [libertarian agent causation])
-
- Posts: 79
- Joined: Mon Aug 29, 2022 11:58 am
Re: Free will — an investigation
OK, if we have free will, that seems perfectly reasonable, and useful, to me.henry quirk wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 3:52 pm As a free will: I can begin, end, and bend at least some causal chains.
...but yesterday does influence my today, surely? I don't exist in isolation; I have a past; I have memories of things that have happened in that past. Without this 'tail' of history, I begin every day anew, with no discernable path or course previously established. My life becomes a succession of unconnected days, each one independent of all that came before. This doesn't seem to accord with the impressions I have of my real-world life. Have I misunderstood something?
Pattern-chaser wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 3:17 pm 2. In contrast, what are the freedoms that free will does not, or cannot, bestow, if any?
This too seems reasonable to me.henry quirk wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 3:52 pm Bein' a free will only means I can try: it doesn't guarantee success or that my choices are wise or right.
- henry quirk
- Posts: 14706
- Joined: Fri May 09, 2008 8:07 pm
- Location: Right here, a little less busy.
Re: Free will — an investigation
Seems so. As I say, yesterday doesn't determine my today. Of course, yesterday influences and informs my today: but it doesn't determine my today.Have I misunderstood something?
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 22504
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: Free will — an investigation
The power to make a choice. That is, a "will" not predetermined by prior impersonal forces.Pattern-chaser wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 3:17 pm This topic seeks to clarify free will. I have two questions to start with; you may have more to add?
1. What freedom(s) does free will bestow?
It doesn't "bestow" anything else.2. In contrast, what are the freedoms that free will does not, or cannot, bestow, if any?
It's not a promise of absolute freedom from influence, constraint or input from material facts. One has to choose either with, or in spite of such things. It's not a promise that whatever anybody wants to be true will become true. It's not a guarantee that you cannot surrender your will, if you so choose. It's not a promise of "happiness" on your own terms, or lack of responsibility, or even freedom from oppressive forces and persons. It most certainly does not ever mean "without consequences"; free will presupposes that you will both choose and face those. Most of all, "free" must not be misrepresented as meaning, "total liberty." No such thing is ever available, nor is any such thing every implied. It only means that within the vicissitudes and circumstances of life, one has say as to what one does.
But it is also, as John Locke so clearly put it, premised on the reality God will hold each person accountable for his or her own choices, and that claiming, "I could not have done otherwise" will never work.
Because of that, free will makes morality possible, and moral accountability certain. So it implies, "Choose wisely."
-
- Posts: 79
- Joined: Mon Aug 29, 2022 11:58 am
Re: Free will — an investigation
Fair enough.
-
- Posts: 79
- Joined: Mon Aug 29, 2022 11:58 am
Re: Free will — an investigation
Oops! With appropriate attribution:
Pattern-chaser wrote:Have I misunderstood something?
henry quirk wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 4:23 pm Seems so. As I say, yesterday doesn't determine my today. Of course, yesterday influences and informs my today: but it doesn't determine my today.
- henry quirk
- Posts: 14706
- Joined: Fri May 09, 2008 8:07 pm
- Location: Right here, a little less busy.
Re: Free will — an investigation
Great Crom on His mountain, have we reached sumthin' approachin' accord before the end of the first page?
In this place: that's an accomplishment.
for everyone!
In this place: that's an accomplishment.
for everyone!
Re: Free will — an investigation
Fun investigation. Here's how it looks to me...
Free will enables us to do anything a creator of our capability can do. We are creators of much of the experience that we have. We choose how to react and respond to other creations. We choose what to believe. We may feed beliefs and create more stories. We may create a reality of which we are a uniquely special star.
We can attempt to draw others in or automatically impose our creations or stories on them. We may claim that much is out of our control or that we're just following commandments because it is a god's will and we are merely a devoted servant. We can create self-fulfilling prophecies to prove ourselves good and right. We can be dangerous, twisted little gods with our free-will creations!
With free will, we can continually explore and expand our awareness and ability. We need not blame or attribute anything to anyone else when explaining what we are. There are influences... but they're like shades of color on a palette that we freely create with.
Without free will, how or why would we do any of these things?
Free will enables us to do anything a creator of our capability can do. We are creators of much of the experience that we have. We choose how to react and respond to other creations. We choose what to believe. We may feed beliefs and create more stories. We may create a reality of which we are a uniquely special star.
We can attempt to draw others in or automatically impose our creations or stories on them. We may claim that much is out of our control or that we're just following commandments because it is a god's will and we are merely a devoted servant. We can create self-fulfilling prophecies to prove ourselves good and right. We can be dangerous, twisted little gods with our free-will creations!
With free will, we can continually explore and expand our awareness and ability. We need not blame or attribute anything to anyone else when explaining what we are. There are influences... but they're like shades of color on a palette that we freely create with.
Without free will, how or why would we do any of these things?
Re: Free will — an investigation
Which causal chains are those, Henry?I am a free will. I am a point of causal & creative power. I begin, end, and bend at least some causal chains.
- henry quirk
- Posts: 14706
- Joined: Fri May 09, 2008 8:07 pm
- Location: Right here, a little less busy.
Re: Free will — an investigation
Do you think this applies equally to everybody's causal chains that they are involved in?henry quirk wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 5:44 pmThe ones I'm involved in, or that I involve myself in, and the ones I begin.
Does this apply to the causal chains of other animals and plants, or only men?