It is a rational and of intellectual integrity to express in the context of the whole book rather than cherry pick here and there.Sculptor wrote: ↑Tue May 03, 2022 9:35 amDO not change the goal posts, by watering down your statement, please.Veritas Aequitas wrote: ↑Tue May 03, 2022 4:11 amTo start with, there is already a possibility of truth to my claim, i.e. eat as much fats as one can without excessive storing to an obese state.Sculptor wrote: ↑Mon May 02, 2022 11:27 am
There is nothing to deflect except your misunderstanding. You fall in to the category of bad science that Taubes has written about; once you say something you are incapable of seeing that it is false and will defend it without regard to reason and evidence.
How would you interpret this phrase?:
"The idea that we can eat as much fat as we want without storing some as excess might be true for some of us but not for all of us"
Do you think it has the same meaning as :
"you can eat as much fat as you want and not gain weight"
Answers on a postcard to:
PO Box get a life.
Try Reading Something House
Nevernever land.
If you want to continue with the discussion then please answer my question before continuiing.Don't be a patronising twat, it makes you look stupid.
I suggest you read the whole book thoroughly.
start here....
"The idea that we can eat as much fat as we want without storing some as excess might be true for some of us but not for all of us"
Do you think it has the same meaning as :
"you can eat as much fat as you want and not gain weight"
As I had explained there is more to the above plain statement.
The "but not for all of us" is applicable to Taubes because he is very sensitive to carbs and has the tendency to exceed the insulin threshold, thus is triggered into fat storage.
What is critical in the above statement is 'can eat'.
Taubes stated re the self-limiting factor of fats;
- "Among the more common explanations was that an eating pattern without Carbohydrates and with plenty of fat was either so boring or so nauseating that people couldn’t and wouldn’t eat as much as they preferred." -Chapter 11.
Elsewhere Taubes did mention along the line,
"you can eat as much fat as you want and not gain weight"
and without qualification "but not for all of us."
I did not bookmark it, so I am trying to find that statement in the book.
Btw, the statement,
"you can eat as much fat as you want and not gain weight"
with the necessary qualifications and strict conditions,
is the general view with KETO and not merely Taubes.
Your sick argument is you keep insisting on arguing only the bare statement,
"you can eat as much fat as you want and not gain weight"
without the b]necessary qualifications[/b] and strict conditions I have stated.