I believe it's continuous. That's because I've read that space isn't empty (due to QM) and space is part of our universe.
Any thoughts?
PhilX
Is the universe continuous or discrete?

 Posts: 5636
 Joined: Sun Aug 31, 2014 7:39 am

 Posts: 406
 Joined: Wed Jan 06, 2010 6:54 am
 Location: USA
Re: Is the universe continuous or discrete?
I've wondered about this, too, PhilX. On the one hand, I've heard about things occurring in "quanta", which are discrete steps such as energy levels in electrons in an atom, or the idea that light consists of discrete photons. Also, there is the question of the limits of how well we can measure things  to within plus or minus X amount. The speed of light in a vacuum, for example, is only known to within a specific amount of measurement uncertainty.
Is it that things in the universe are truly continuous and we are just limited in how well we can measure them, or is it that ultimately things in the universe occur in finite packages?
Is it that things in the universe are truly continuous and we are just limited in how well we can measure them, or is it that ultimately things in the universe occur in finite packages?
Re: Is the universe continuous or discrete?
What makes anyone think the question is even meaningful?
That is, why should the mutually exclusive categories "discrete" and "continuous" be regarded as pertaining to the world, as opposed to being artifacts of our minds?
That is, why should the mutually exclusive categories "discrete" and "continuous" be regarded as pertaining to the world, as opposed to being artifacts of our minds?
Re: Is the universe continuous or discrete?
Difficult question and I don't think anyone can know the answer for sure. I believe reality can be seen as an infinite continuous something, which we can conceptualize as a multiverse. If you were God you could zoom "in" and "out" in it forever. (This is what I've come to understand even though I'm a "particle" guy.)
Our universe, at least as it appears to us, is however a finite part of this field, and we humans are also finite. So the universe appears as both continuous and discrete at the same time to us. Everything is still interconnected, continuous and nonseparable with everything else in it, but by the very virtue, inherent circularity of being it and looking at it at the same time, we see it as more and more discrete, eventually completely discrete (discreteness is kinda the reciprocal of continuousness). The inherent finiteness also puts limitations on what we can do, so we run into Plancklengths; I would argue that Plancklengths may be characteristic of our universe and/or human understanding, but they aren't really fundamental.
Our universe, at least as it appears to us, is however a finite part of this field, and we humans are also finite. So the universe appears as both continuous and discrete at the same time to us. Everything is still interconnected, continuous and nonseparable with everything else in it, but by the very virtue, inherent circularity of being it and looking at it at the same time, we see it as more and more discrete, eventually completely discrete (discreteness is kinda the reciprocal of continuousness). The inherent finiteness also puts limitations on what we can do, so we run into Plancklengths; I would argue that Plancklengths may be characteristic of our universe and/or human understanding, but they aren't really fundamental.
Re: Is the universe continuous or discrete?
Why must it be either/or? Why not both? QM seems to suggest that our perception of the universe consists of stopmoments in an evermoving continuum.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests