Nope. The design allowed for sin to be possible, not for sin to be unavoidable.Sculptor wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 11:03 amGod made adma god made eve.VVilliam wrote: ↑Wed Mar 10, 2021 6:50 pmSince sin is the breaking of imposed rules then regardless of the gods behaviour one cannot acurately cliam that the god sinned unless the god himself was breaking imposed rules...rules which we know nothing about so cannot make the call either way.
We can suspect..
But that is about all we can do.
Remembering that Adam was the first one to imply that the god was at fault...indirectly at fault but at fault irregardless.
He made them, they sin. The sin is his design.
Who Sinned First?
Re: Who Sinned First?
Re: Who Sinned First?
Exactly, God knew they would sin when he made them; he's omniscient.VVilliam wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 4:27 pmNope. The design allowed for sin to be possible, not for sin to be unavoidable.Sculptor wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 11:03 amGod made adma god made eve.VVilliam wrote: ↑Wed Mar 10, 2021 6:50 pm
Since sin is the breaking of imposed rules then regardless of the gods behaviour one cannot acurately cliam that the god sinned unless the god himself was breaking imposed rules...rules which we know nothing about so cannot make the call either way.
We can suspect..
But that is about all we can do.
Remembering that Adam was the first one to imply that the god was at fault...indirectly at fault but at fault irregardless.
He made them, they sin. The sin is his design.
He designed them to play a cosmic game in which humanity suffer whilst god watches.
Re: Who Sinned First?
Even if that were the actual case, unless there was a law which the god was breaking, the god has not sinned. Show me that law and I can agree with you.
On top of that, if there is no one to punish the god, then your point becomes moot.
Last edited by VVilliam on Thu Mar 11, 2021 4:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Who Sinned First?
The myth of Genesis was wasted upon you.
The garden of eden was devoid of sin and suffering. It was perfect. If perfection and lack of suffering was what Adam and Eve wanted - they could've stayed.
But they wanted something else.
You know, like 40 year old virgins who still live in their parents' basement. It's safe, and perfect and everything's provided for them. If that's the life you want, you gotta abide by the house rules of mommy and daddy.
Re: Who Sinned First?
God can stop watching his drama anytime he wants. No drama ever happened without it being recorded for viewing evidence that it happened. No audience, no player, no play. It's all pretty much staged, just a silly pantomine full of boos and cheers for ones own entertainment and pleasure, it's all no-self selfing.VVilliam wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 4:53 pmEven if that were the actual case, unless there was a law which the god was breaking, the god has not sinned. Show me that law and I can agree with you.
On top of that, if there is no one to punish the god, then your point becomes moot.
.
Re: Who Sinned First?
It has a purpose - - -Dontaskme wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 7:22 pmGod can stop watching his drama anytime he wants. No drama ever happened without it being recorded for viewing evidence that it happened. No audience, no player, no play. It's all pretty much staged, just a silly pantomine full of boos and cheers for ones own entertainment and pleasure, it's all no-self selfing.
.
It can inspire...
I am inspired by the story [overall biblical stories] to see God in a certain way.
[As an example, such stories inspire me to think about the God in the following way;]
He is a recognizable being and has a recognizable form which is Hermaphrodite, but he leans toward the male aspect of his makeup.
From The Story inspired by YHWH:
Genesis 1/27
So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him;
YHWH is the product of the combined melding of creative abilities of a Father and a Mother Creator. He has an Hermaphrodite parent. The parent is the creator of the God YHWH. Such parents create Gods as offspring.
From The Story inspired by YHWH:
Genesis 1/27
male and female created he them.
In this YHWH split the Hermaphrodite aspects into a pair. Each of the pair represent the differing aspects of YHWH.
I think I am inspired by YHWH to know these things about YHWH...through the biblical accounts which YHWH inspired humans to write.
Re: Who Sinned First?
I'm not inspired by other authors stories.
I prefer my own story. The one I write. At least I can trust that story, to not lie to me, for real truths can only come straight from the sources mouth.
Re: Who Sinned First?
Then Adam and Eve did not sin either.VVilliam wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 4:53 pmEven if that were the actual case, unless there was a law which the god was breaking, the god has not sinned. Show me that law and I can agree with you.
On top of that, if there is no one to punish the god, then your point becomes moot.
BTW
Sin is not illegal.
Why should sin involve punishment?
Re: Who Sinned First?
Your words are wasted on me, because I do not give a fuck what you think.Skepdick wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 4:56 pmThe myth of Genesis was wasted upon you.
The garden of eden was devoid of sin and suffering. It was perfect. If perfection and lack of suffering was what Adam and Eve wanted - they could've stayed.
But they wanted something else.
You know, like 40 year old virgins who still live in their parents' basement. It's safe, and perfect and everything's provided for them. If that's the life you want, you gotta abide by the house rules of mommy and daddy.
Re: Who Sinned First?
But are you sure in that, that you are seeing your story in a truthful manner? That of course is something only you and everyone else can answer for themselves.
But when we bounce this off of one another, it should show truthfulness...
Last edited by VVilliam on Thu Mar 11, 2021 8:44 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Who Sinned First?
Since there was a rule imposed, and that rule was broken, yes - it [the action of the sin] can be said to have been illegal.Sculptor wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 8:35 pmThen Adam and Eve did not sin either.
BTW
Sin is not illegal.
Why should sin involve punishment?
Re: Who Sinned First?
Interjecting, the need to let you know appears to be so that you should understand that your words are wasted in that area. The question might then become, "So why do you [feel the need to] waste words in that area?"
Re: Who Sinned First?
Nah, he has some unresolved emotional issues.
He doesn't care what I think but he feels the need to tell me that.
So he cares enough to tell me that he doesn't care. Pity the fool.
Re: Who Sinned First?
This is a funny story.Sculptor wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 8:35 pmThen Adam and Eve did not sin either.
BTW
Sin is not illegal.
Why should sin involve punishment?
God created himself in his own image and then punished himself for doing exactly what he told himself not to do.
hahahahah!! ... it just couldn't make it up. Oh wait, it did make itself up...hahahahaha!!