Philosophy Now Forum

There is a fallacy rampant about these parts, but for which I know no name... The bare bones of the fallacy are the simple shouts: "nobody understands me"; " all I see is strawmen"; "everybody ad homs me" ...or ... "in the DAyS whEn THIS wrITTen so caLLED "AD...

Maybe you should also refrain from suspecting things, it would be best for everyone :) What would be best for everyone is for you stop wasting forum space with your drivel. I'm not the one wasting forum space with a long lecture about how the NTS is a formal fallacy, which however only proves your ...

Could Searle's Chinese Room qualify as a NTS fallacy? 1. No computer(program) understands language. 2. ChatGPT understands language. 3. No computer (program) truly understands language. What does Searle mean by "understand"? Does the man in the room not understand the language the instruct...

In all your comments, including this one, why do you think we're mocking you? :) I don't know, but I suspect that because you haven't been able to falsify anything I've said, and would rather be a troll (given your own definition), that you are jealous and have nothing better to do than to be a tro...

Have you read any of Age's posts? What on Earth makes you think he's accurately calling out fallacies? Age is one of the people who's post I don't read because I have already interacted with them and found them to be lacking in critical thinking skills as well as being intellectually dishonest. I w...

What is a Jew? Seems like there are two possible definitions, neither of which contradicts the other: 1: a person belonging to a continuation through descent or conversion of the ancient Jewish people 2: one whose religion is Judaism A Jew is the offspring of a Jewish mother. You definition is just...

Because you're looking for some rational structure in the NTS but it doesn't have one. And where did I say or imply such a thing. You can't even quote me on what it is you are disagreeing with me about. What I have shown is that there isn't even a rational structure in the first premise made that m...

David Friedman, the conservative former US ambassador to Israel during Donald Trump’s presidency, went further, tweeting before Monday’s protest: “ Any American Jew attending this rally is not a Jew – yes I said it!” I think Mr. Freidman's position probably falls into the NTS. He already called the...

All very nice but the NTS is still just an intentional dick move, not a formal fallacy. :) You already "lost" in this topic before my first comment. Where did I ever say it was a formal fallacy? You're not really reading my posts, only Flash's misinterpretation of my posts. Because you're...

There is a fallacy rampant about these parts, but for which I know no name... The bare bones of the fallacy are the simple shouts: "nobody understands me"; " all I see is strawmen"; "everybody ad homs me" ...or ... "in the DAyS whEn THIS wrITTen so caLLED "AD...

There is a fallacy rampant about these parts, but for which I know no name... The bare bones of the fallacy are the simple shouts: "nobody understands me"; " all I see is strawmen"; "everybody ad homs me" ...or ... "in the DAyS whEn THIS wrITTen so caLLED "AD...

However there is a real pattern that it is focusing on. Advocate has been acting from the beginning as if the NTS meant that if you exclude someone from a category, then you are wrong. And Traffic Logic was assuming that in real disagreements where there is a clear and standing disagreement over in...

Glanced over maybe half of it and skipped the rest. This has got to be some of the most inept trolling I've ever seen. Keep it short geez. If keeping it short is being a troll, then look in the mirror. Besides, my posts aren't for you since I already know you aren't reading them. They are for the r...

Wizard22 wrote: ↑Sun Dec 03, 2023 8:49 am I tried to type that last sentence as sarcastically as I could.

I agree there are true Scotsmen out there in the world, somewhere... likely Scotland.

Yes, I'm sure that is where you will find most of them.

Atla thinks this is a troll post.

If there is a wood then there are trees, ergo you can only see the woods if you can see the trees .... The no wood for trees problem solved!!!!! I saw my wood in your girlfriend's bush last night. Eeeew, stop fucking your own mum you dirty little bastard. So you're saying you date dead people? Now ...