Philosophy Now Forum

An excuse. You were only asked for one thing. One. It could not be simpler for you, and still, you cannot do it. QED. And you have been repeatedly asked for a single objective moral rule. Not and entire system, but one single rules. and you have been weighed and found wanting. You are a failure, a ...

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue May 21, 2024 10:35 pm

Sculptor wrote: ↑Tue May 21, 2024 6:46 pm That is not an answer.

It really is. It’s the ur-answer. If a supernatural power — ...

And this is the moment you depart from Philosophy and retreat into a fantasy world of your own making.

You say "easy," but I don't see one. If it's "easy," where is it? My moral landscape cannot be reduced to a few empty platitudes. An excuse. You were only asked for one thing. One. It could not be simpler for you, and still, you cannot do it. QED. And you have been repeatedly as...

No "moraity" is subjective, actually. And you can test that for yourself. Just go looking for even one Subjectivist moral precept. Easy. You say "easy," but I don't see one. If it's "easy," where is it? My moral landscape cannot be reduced to a few empty platitudes. Bu...

We can see that Subjectivism is indeed a "shack" a badly-constructed idea, and that it is indeed "on fire," since it falls apart at the first sign of logic. It can't even perform the most rudimentary functions of "morality." All moraity is wonderfully subjective and mo...

So do you believe that the communion wine is literally the blood of Jesus and the bread the flesh? I believe in supernatural power that enters our world. That is likely what separates your and my understandings. That is not an answer. Do you believe that it is okay to pay money to the Pope to have ...

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue May 21, 2024 4:02 pm

Sculptor wrote: ↑Tue May 21, 2024 3:33 pm You seem to be dancing around a point.

An odd statement. Every post of mine is composed strictly of points.

Your "points" are supposed to address items in the post you were responding to.

I think it's a public service to point it out. After all, if somebody is trying to live in a shack that's on fire, wouldn't you want to at least tell them they'd better leave it? Seems fair. 8) No shack is on fire, except in your imagination. We can see that Subjectivism is indeed a "shack&quo...

No shack is on fire, except in your imagination. People dont need telling. And are not likely to listen to you given your track record. If you succumb to IC’s “preaching” — he is an absolutely bad apologist for Christianity and also despises Catholicism — you will commit an intellectual error: mist...

Which ones? Protestant, Catholic, Rastafarian, Orthodox, Mormon?? Which ? The last census finds that Atheists are now the majority group is Scotland. This is progress. Catholic theology — the chief Encyclicals and Catholic social doctrine — and certainly a social focus oriented to the supernaturali...

I know. But what is obvious is that for Subjectivists, the word "morality" cannot possibly have any content. It just means, "whatever I feel." And that is not morally commendable: neither others, nor even you can say that makes you objectively "moral." All it means is ...

They tend to form themselves into tiny cabals of like minded fools who think that their personal ideas of morality are objective, absolute and universal. But this is just delusion. When they come across other groups who similarly pretend Objective moral ideas they are affronted and demand that the ...

I know. But what is obvious is that for Subjectivists, the word "morality" cannot possibly have any content. It just means, "whatever I feel." And that is not morally commendable: neither others, nor even you can say that makes you objectively "moral." All it means is ...

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2024 1:08 pm

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2024 10:55 am Are people who regret having had gender surgery being silenced?

Very much so. The "Trans" community will allow as much pro-propaganda as can be generated,

Garbage in Garbage out.
You can rely in IC to spew bollocks constantly

I laid out my opinion as concisely as I could above. If BOTH the child and parent unequivocally want the procedure done to the child after reviewing all the pros and cons, then it's not my business to tell them they're making a mistake. I would never undergo surgery like that but if others want it,...