Philosophy Now Forum

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu May 23, 2024 12:04 am You guys are being silly. The •murder• IC refers to is quite clear. You are just being difficult.

Enough …

The dude had to fake Alzheimer's to get out of the difficulties he caused himself with basic clumsiness ...

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu May 23, 2024 12:48 am You've lost me.

That's becaue you ignore all context as a tactic.

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu May 23, 2024 12:04 am You guys are being silly. The •murder• IC refers to is quite clear. You are just being difficult.

Enough …

IC is clearly wrong. Killings that are justified aren't murders, killings that are unjustified are murders, this is entirely obvious.

I gave you my working definition of what murder is, what is yours? I'm interested in this "objective" definition you have. What is the objective definition of murder? The objective definition is "premeditated killing." If the objective definition of murder were in fact "pre...

The objective definition is "premeditated killing." I think I gave that, did I not. I also explained why that's wrong. Man is created in the image of God, given life by God, and rightfully belongs to God, so to kill him is to act contrary to God. Locke said the same thing, actually. That ...

For them to conceive of morality in the same way we do, they would have to have a whole lot of stuff in common with us and no significant difference. Otherwise the base perceptions that inform their morality will just be incompatible with ours. But those differences are not that relevant to the pic...

I gave you my working definition of what murder is, what is yours? I'm interested in this "objective" definition you have. What is the objective definition of murder? The objective definition is "premeditated killing." I think I gave that, did I not. I also explained why that's ...

But one kind-of question I asked long ago is how would some other being, in another galaxy or planet — a being that had consciousness similar to humankind — how would they conceive of morals? And through what circumstances would The Revelation have been revealed to them? The solution to that conund...

It seems to me that IC has redefined the word, "morality", to match his own preference. When he talks about morality, he is referring to something different to what most of us understand the word to mean. Morality might not be ,a matter of subjective opinion as far as IC is concerned, but...

I genuinely believe that slavery is wrong, but I can't give you a rational explanation for that belief. I can give you a rational explanation as to why I don't want to be enslaved, but I can't give one for why it is wrong for anyone else to be. Now all you have to do is provide the rational explana...

Must be something in the water.:- NO, IT IS THE MOUNTING ACCOUNTS OF ISLAM SCUM ON YOUTUBE - IN YOUR AREA - LONDON He's right that you are in the middle of a psychotic breakdown. The far right Youtube rabbit hole you are in is not helping. Getting egged on by Accelafine, Mannie and Jacobi just beca...

We have a relatively new problem with the forum at the moment, in that the number of spam accounts being registered has dramatically increased, and the quality of their posts (which we have to assess in order to approve them or not) is far higher than before, presumably because the spammers are now...

attofishpi wrote: ↑Sat May 18, 2024 11:45 pm

FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sat May 18, 2024 7:53 pm Did Vegitariantaxidermy die and become the new voice in Fishpie's head?

Haha!!

I miss Veg, especially being slagged off by her (what a turn on) - she was the most intelligent woman on the forum.

Wait, what? This Accelafine personisn't just VT in a new frock?

Atla wrote: ↑Sun May 19, 2024 7:08 am I think Kant would be an indirect realist too today. Even someone as smug as he wouldn't be able to ignore the mountain of evidence for this view.

You have to explicitly tell VA that you are re-using his Hume is/ought argument to mock him. He's too autistic to just pick up on that as subtext.

Did Vegitariantaxidermy die and become the new voice in Fishpie's head?