Janoah wrote: ↑Sun Dec 17, 2023 10:39 pm
But I still didn’t see your moral compass (I only saw the criticism of others in your reasoning). And the moral compass must fit in one sentence, otherwise it is not a compass, but a confusing map.
Oh my general moral compass is Occidental, Greco-Christian; a general appreciation and respect for our defined 'moral categories'; our developed system of jurisprudence. I cannot deny my Reform backgrounding but as you know Reform is not
real Judaism.
A *moral compass*, to push on your metaphor, is a device one holds in one's hand. Your metaphor places it outside of oneself and in an *object*. You either have one or you don't. But what we determine is moral is what we
feel to be moral, and that is determined on an inner plane.
Where I admit to confusion is that I am in a process of rejecting the Judeo-Christian concept of a god who *gave the Law*. Or perhaps I should say I reject, and in some sense despise, that ugly, solitary, brutish figure as he is pictured in the OT. That beast, that animal, that tyrant, is simply not to my liking, and what he produces in the people who emulate him is definitely not to my liking. But I do acknowledge the duality in that
imago. There is another side just as a schizophrenic has a sort of split personality I guess.
So my view is that
that god-concept must be revised. However I am in doubt as to whether it is necessary to disassociate from it entirely and to establish an new god-concept. I might be able to pull that off, but it would be an individual's work. Meanwhile everyone else will have to carry on with what they have and what they can access. Frankly I relate to a god-picture that is Vedantic. I mean as far as established god-concepts and pictures go.
So for a *moral compass* I would say Platonic and Vedantic with a clear awareness that I am a product of Occidental culture and that already established moral system.
A map is something used to guide you through a territory. I do not offer a map. I can only describe my own processes in relation to *mapping*.