Spacetime is a fundamental aspect of reality without it nothing can be caused.
The mind is omnipresent in space-time
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
AND, 'existence' is ANOTHER fundamental aspect of 'reality', and without 'it' nothing can be caused. But, SO WHAT?
Also, 'matter' is ANOTHER fundamental aspect of 'reality', and without 'it' nothing can be caused. But, AGAIN, SO WHAT?
Furthermore, 'space' is YET ANOTHER fundamental aspect of 'reality', and without 'it' nothing can be caused. But, ONCE AGAIN, SO WHAT?
However, 'time', itself, is NOT A fundamental aspect of 'reality', and without 'it' 'things' were, and are, STILL caused. But, ONCE MORE, SO WHAT?
By the way, let 'us' NOT FORGET that 'you' have YET TO DEFINE the words 'mind', 'space', 'time', 'spacetime', AND 'space-time' in A WAY that MAKES PERFECT SENSE, or which FIT IN PERFECTLY WITH OTHER words and 'their' DEFINITIONS.
And, until 'you' DO, what 'you' are talking ABOUT and REFERRING TO here 'you' REALLY HAVE NO FULL COMPREHENSION nor UNDERSTANDING OF, YET.
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
'you', "bahman", were ASKED a QUESTION, for CLARIFICATION, or an ANSWER, 'you' here, however, have REFUSED TO ANSWER the ACTUAL QUESTION ASKED.
Now, will 'you' INFORM 'us' of what the word 'spacetime' MEANS, or REFERS TO, TO 'you', EXACTLY?
If no, then WHY NOT?
So, TO "bahman" there ARE or IS A 'thing/s', which BEGIN, or HAVE A BEGINNING, but YET were/was NOT 'caused' AT ALL.
Which, I WONDER, 'If "bahman" will EVER EXPLAIN how 'this' could even BE A POSSIBILITY, let alone BEING AN ACTUALITY?
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
Time has a beginning since it cannot expand into the infinite past. It does not have a cause since that leads to regress. I am not going to discuss this with you any further since you believe in eternal time and also believe that regress is possible. We have been through this several times.Age wrote: ↑Sat Dec 23, 2023 11:15 pm'you', "bahman", were ASKED a QUESTION, for CLARIFICATION, or an ANSWER, 'you' here, however, have REFUSED TO ANSWER the ACTUAL QUESTION ASKED.
Now, will 'you' INFORM 'us' of what the word 'spacetime' MEANS, or REFERS TO, TO 'you', EXACTLY?
If no, then WHY NOT?So, TO "bahman" there ARE or IS A 'thing/s', which BEGIN, or HAVE A BEGINNING, but YET were/was NOT 'caused' AT ALL.
Which, I WONDER, 'If "bahman" will EVER EXPLAIN how 'this' could even BE A POSSIBILITY, let alone BEING AN ACTUALITY?
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
So, space time had a beginning, but were uncaused.
Does that mean they are the “first cause”? The self rolling wheel?
Did space time begin to exist?
Was there something for which space and time came into existence for? Or are spacetime synonymous with existence?
Is a mind required for the transition from non existence of space time to existence of space time?
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
Yes.
No. The stuff that makes the universe may exist at the beginning of time or may have a cause.
No.
No.
No.
No, the mind is a substance that experiences and causes, in simple words it produces change, but to do that it requires to experience first.
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
Are you suggesting space is not physical?
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
Spacetime is a substance. By physical I mean, stuff like objects, electrons, protons, light, and the like.
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
So are you saying that space is not made of particles?Spacetime is a substance. By physical I mean, stuff like objects, electrons, protons, light, and the like.
("Time" is a concept yes?)
Re: The mind is omnipresent in space-time
"bahman" will you;
Firstly, define what the words below actually mean and refer to, to you, exactly?
Then, list the order of those words when they came to exist? Starting with what eternally exists, if there are any to you.
Mind.
Universe.
Space.
Time.
Matter.
Spacetime
Firstly, define what the words below actually mean and refer to, to you, exactly?
Then, list the order of those words when they came to exist? Starting with what eternally exists, if there are any to you.
Mind.
Universe.
Space.
Time.
Matter.
Spacetime