You still don't get it.Eodnhoj7 wrote: ↑Sun Jan 03, 2021 1:05 am1. Yet hallucinations are composed of images of already existing phenomenon, they are images seperated from the source much in the same manner the mirage of water is the image of water seperated from the source.Veritas Aequitas wrote: ↑Wed Dec 30, 2020 6:04 amAs I had stated there is nothing to mirror about a hallucination.
A hallucination is merely activities in the brain.
The phenomenon itself is the meta-hallucination,
However what mirrors the phenomenon is the noumenon.
The noumenon is a sub-hallucination of the meta-hallucination.
Prove to me a higher reality exists as real beyond the meta-hallucination?
If you cannot prove it as real, then it is unreal.
Hallucinations are merely activities in the brain.
A mirage is generally an empirical illusion within nature not in the human brain.
Generally a hallucination is based on what is already in the brain via nature or nurture.
Note the differentiation between meta-hallucination by all humans and typical hallucination by SOME humans.2. If all is a hallucination then the activities of the brain are hallucinations as well.
Yes, the activities of the brain are also hallucinations but within meta-hallucination.
If you want to prove the apple on the table is real, what do you need to do?3. What constitutes proof?
What is needed is to verify and justify the apple is real by seeing, touching, biting, smelling, etc. that justify to all concern it is a real apple.
A more credible proof would be subject the apple to scientific tests [physical, biological, genetics] to confirm it is an apple as defined scientifically.
If you insist whatever you claimed as beyond human is real, then do the above tests.