Philosophy Now Forum

However, for example in criminal law, there is a much stronger emphasis on victim compensation in Islamic law, while western law seems to care more about punishment with victim compensation being rather an afterthought, if even. The West has a fair degree of victim compensation as well. That's what...

The emperor must acknowledge that he has no right to overrule Sharia law that governs "marriage, succession, inheritance and charities among Muslims". Hmm. I guess it would depend upon what those laws are concerning marriage, succession, inheritance and charities, that Sharia insists upon...

The emperor must acknowledge that he has no right to overrule Sharia law that governs "marriage, succession, inheritance and charities among Muslims". Hmm. I guess it would depend upon what those laws are concerning marriage, succession, inheritance and charities, that Sharia insists upon...

Gazza - this is what godelian - as so many Muslims are Wolves in Sheeps clothing - this is what he refuses to admit to stating (coward liar):- We believe in Allah while the emperor believes in his own fake inventions. We will keep engaging the emperor in battle, defeat him, and force him on his kne...

Did you bother to watch what he had to put up with growing up among Pakistani Muslims? In your sick fantasy, these Pakistani Muslims should have forcibly converted him to Islam. Apparently, that did not happen. So, again more evidence of how sick your imagination seems to be! Weren't you insisting ...

If you were to put a video and sound recording device in the forest when no one was around and a tree did fall close enough to the recording device, then would you be able to better answer your question here, or at least answer it more efficiently or more effectively? That's an interesting question...

I gave you my working definition of what murder is, what is yours? I'm interested in this "objective" definition you have. What is the objective definition of murder? The objective definition is "premeditated killing." I think I gave that, did I not. I also explained why that's ...

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2024 9:21 pm

Harbal wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2024 8:40 pm But you can't, can you?

Sure I can.

Then please do, by all means. I gave you my working definition of what murder is, what is yours? I'm interested in this "objective" definition you have. What is the objective definition of murder?

I would leave it up to the female. Wait. So it's not okay for men to commit premeditated murder. But it IS okay for women to murder? :shock: Just bear in mind that legal abortion isn't murder, Gary. Tell him to look it up in a law book if he doesn't believe you. Let's give IC a chance to tell us wh...

I 100% do not advocate for convenience murder. I can assure you of that. Okay. So we're not using the tragic case of a young woman, exploiting it to excuse the very different situation of the vast preponderance of abortions. Good. OK. So we have a start. Are we to assume then that aborting the preg...

I am absolutely NOT using the post above to justify all abortions. A pre-born baby is a human being's preborn baby as far as I'm aware. I know not more than that. I'll even give you my answer afterward to the scenario to boot. Does that sound fair? You can critique it as much as you wish. Yes, fair...

But we'll be fair and turn the other ear and pretend that didn't happen. Let us hear your objective grounds for your decision regarding the lady with the psychopath's baby, IC.

They're not rape abortions, or incest abortions, or anything of that kind. Less than 1% are those. So if you will begin by agreeing with me that 99% of abortions are immoral, I'll answer your question for you. You haven't told him why you think they are immoral, so how does he know what he is being...

As a Christian who claims to have "objective" morality at your calling, maybe you can give a definitive answer as to the following: A woman is raped by a psychopathic male and is impregnated. She wants no part of having that man's baby. Is it OK for her to abort the fetus before giving bi...

It's funny...I embark on a proof, and all you can say is that "I'm not doing it." :shock: Well, I guess we'll have to throw the ball back in your court, and ask what it is you would accept as proof of objective morality. I'm ready to try, if you can say what you'd ever accept... :? I gave...